Skip to content
Brit Vault Review

The Proposal to Overhaul the Youth Development Structure and Help Youth Players

Among the most cherished moments during this campaign arrived the other day, watching a homegrown player surge forward from his defensive 18-yard line to seal a clinching finish.

Homegrown talents are always appreciated by their club's followers and, judging by early glimpses, the faithful are likely to enjoy many more special performances from him in the years to come.

Yet, for a single success story, there are countless of other boys and girls who are not successful past the various phases, and must cope with a shattering rejection at a formative age.

It is these players who drop out of youth football that I am concerned about, because I don't think the existing system does enough to inform them about their chances, or support them when they are released.

It requires an overhaul and, when I left management, I put together my own analysis into the academy system, featuring suggestions for how it could be bettered.

A Huge Outlay – With Certain Substantial Benefits

The outlook on academies is not only as a former coach. My family members are in the programme, so I've got a vested interest too.

For all young footballers, the goal of becoming a professional player is a powerful one. The academy system has been put in place to give them the best chance to realise that dream, with a specific plan being launched over a decade ago.

Currently, many thousands of young players are in the setup, at clubs from the highest division down. It's an all-encompassing structure, with sessions at least three nights a week and a fixtures schedule that consumes most of their weekends.

The same programme is now being used by the fastest-growing sport, women's football, too.

These academies are resourced at extraordinary levels and provide work for trainers, physios, doctors and many more administrative staff.

The amenities are of the highest level, with excellent indoor and outdoor surfaces. Education is included too, with lecturers hired to run compulsory academic programmes.

The financial commitment is immense but, as we have observed, the teams at the pinnacle are securing substantial returns on that investment through temporary transfers and sales of the young players.

The performance of the Present System?

The primary development programme has been in operation for almost 15 years now, so how has it fared to the scrutiny of time?

Academies now operate a pre-academy programme for kids from the age of six, so if any of them complete the full programme they would complete at 21. That's more time than a child spends in mainstream school, and lasts his whole childhood.

These youngsters are given with team uniform and jackets, all badged up, and are seen by peers and family as being part of that club.

Their sense of self has, practically, been stamped on them at a early age and they also have to make a full commitment to the academy schedule.

That means coaching on three nights a week, and a games schedule taking up most of the weekend, are now a key component of a young player's aim to pursue his ambition.

From my findings, in a lot of cases what happens at school is seen as being less important, with the academy assuming primary importance and evolving into the main concern of the child and his parents' life.

Some families see a pot of gold at the end of the path if their child becomes a professional and place immense pressure on their backs to make it.

Unfortunately, data show the system has a total disparity of achievement and non-achievement. We all see the successful ones, but we hardly ever see those who are released.

Be Frank About Their Chances

I have no desire to take those hopes away from young players but we must be pragmatic with them about their prospects.

While there are certain individuals a club will identify as being potential professionals, the truth is many of the boys have only been on the journey to occupy the positions needed for practice and the weekend fixtures at each age group.

I genuinely believe academies adequately communicate the understandings of these players or guardians, about where they stand in the wider process.

Players and parents need to be given a full evaluation of where they rate, so they can prepare for the likely letdown when it arrives.

Our academies have nurtured some outstanding players and there is more consideration paid to player welfare now than in the past, but let's also introduce a bit more focus on honesty too.

More Emphasis on Schooling

As I stated above, I feel many youngsters joining academies actually take more notice of their trainers at times than they do of their educators.

It's crucial this is acknowledged within the academy system, and academy heads communicate this directive to the coaches at each age group.

This situation itself is nothing new. Guidance played a significant part in my upbringing, and PE teachers and coaches were always held in great regard.

But, for those running an academy, they must guarantee the coaches are given clear direction and appreciation of their duty because of the impact they have.

Principles of decorum, discipline and effort should be as demanding as they are in any academic environment – and should relate to the scholastic side of the child's life there too.

The framework I have suggested would have increased emphasis on education and mentoring – for families as well as the youth players – and also support for what comes next if they are dropped aged 16.

My Plan to Assist Young Players

I would organise academies within six zones, each overseen by a director and partner them with approved schools and colleges.

Before they get to scholarship level, players would be assessed at 14 to see what education pathway fits them.

At 16, players starting apprenticeships would register in a required combined education programme with the academic partners.

At the same time, the players who are released at 16, can start a full-time combined academic programme with the schools or colleges.

The positive for them would be the provision of a new competitive programme where the schools and colleges would

MS
The writer

Michele Sloan

UK-based journalist specializing in product analysis and consumer advocacy.

Brit Vault Review

Type to search articles.